By Chuck Slater
As a youngster, Elsa Neubauer was always athletic. Soccer. Dance. Lacrosse. Then, as a Brewster high-school freshman last year, she discovered cross-country. It’s been running ever since.
Elsa Neubauer trains with the boys. (PHOTO COURTESY OF JOSEPH SCELIA)
How good a runner is 15-year-old Elsa Neubauer? Scary good. So good she runs against the boys in practice. “We have a good girls cross-country team,” says the Brewster coach, Joe Scelia. “But for Elsa, it’s running with the boys.”
Scelia didn’t know anything about this slender 5-foot, 5¼-inch freshman a year ago. He certainly does now. Elsa opened the cross-country season by winning the girls Division 1 Race at Somers High’s Big Red Invitational in 19:18.26. It was merely the fastest time recorded by a girl in the 34-school, 1,600-athlete meet. After winning a second invitational she traveled to Rhode Island and won the Ocean State Invitational.
But the week before, she lost, coming in third in the Bob Pratt Invitational on Long Island. The two girls who beat her are ranked 1 and 2 in the state. With her season in full swing, she could lose again in a major meet but the goal is to do well enough at the state qualifier to make it to the state meet upstate on November 11th. Count on it.
“She’s one of the top 10 in the state,” Scelia said. “To my knowledge she’s the most impressively improved athlete in the state. She keeps getting better every day. She is turning into a complete runner.” And a very dedicated one. “She is mentally tough,” the coach said, “and willing to push herself beyond normal limits.”
All pretty incredible for a youngster who had never run competitively until the 9th grade and who started her season on the freshman JV while her one-year-younger brother Ryan also took up the sport.
“I had never run but I always liked running,” Elsa said. “When in soccer we would have to do extra laps for punishment, I loved it. I just run now and I love it. I love the feeling of it, and the trying to get better. And I really enjoy the competition.”
But what about running against and perhaps beating the boys? Do they mind? “No, not really,” said Elsa Neubauer. “They all know it’s to help all of us.” Scott Jacobson, a top Brewster runner agrees. “There’s nothing more to say,” he said. “She’s just as tough as nails.”
October 18, 2017 | admin
By Chuck Slater
Brett Makar had a fantastic football season as a junior as Yorktown made it to the Class A final. He’s on pace to do even better his senior year as the Cornhuskers have gotten off to an undefeated start to the season. Yet he will probably never play major competitive football after this season.
Brett Makar is even better in lacrosse. (PHOTO COURTESY OF BRETT MAKAR)
Makar, who if anything is even better in lacrosse, has accepted a scholarship to Maryland University in that sport. And college coaches don’t want to see their scholarship athletes risking injury in another sport, particularly one as rugged as football. Plus, at 6 feet and 185 pounds, Makar is plenty big for high-school football but would find bigger foes at the college level.
Not playing further football — a game he started at age 8 in the Yorktown A.C. — is a reality sinking in slowly. “I haven’t really thought about it that much,” Makar said shortly after Yorktown went to 4-0 by rallying in the final minute to beat a tough Rye, 34-30, while trailing 14-0 early. “But definitely my heart is in lacrosse.”
A relevant example is former John Jay star Terersa Swertfager, on a college softball scholarship, and thus unable to play college volleyball after being the best high-school libero these eyes ever saw.
Yorktown lacrosse coach Sean Carney has a similar view of Makar, who plays defense for him and earned All-America designation. “He’s the best athlete I’ve ever coached here.” Carney said. “Any time we face a team with a player we have to stop, we put Brett on him.”
Meanwhile, Makar is making the most of his time on the gridiron, both on offense and defense. He is in his second season as a two-way starter/star. As a junior, Makar was the area’s Player of the Year and gained 1,584 yards from scrimmage while scoring 21 touchdowns. In the first three games this season, he had 45 carries for 516 yards and six touchdowns including a hard-to-believe effort in which he rallied his team from a 14-7 deficit to a 28-14 victory over Hen Hud while rushing for 215 yards and two touchdowns and catching a pass, plus on defense making eight tackles, an interception, a sack and a fumble recovery.
In game 4, Rye understandably keyed on him, limiting him to 60 yards on the ground. But his teammates stepped up, which pleased Makar no end. “We lost a lot of great players from last season,” said Makar, “but the guys certainly stepped up. I love these guys and I love playing with them — a lot since the third grade. It’s a special group.”
And one that could go far again. Don’t bet against the Huskers making the playoffs. And don’t bet against Makar leading them.
October 11, 2017 | admin
By Chuck Slater
Caitlyn Ferrante avenged a sectional upset. (PHOTO COURTESY OF CAITLYN FERRANTE)
Veteran Yorktown High tennis coach Roger Dayer got an early look at the athlete who is Number 1 on his girls tennis team hitting the ball — a very early look. Caitlyn Ferrante was all of three years old. “Her brother Rob was the first man on my boys team,” Dayer related. “When we won the sectional final, his little sister came out on the court and hit with him.” “I used to travel with him all the time,” Caitlyn said. “I started playing when I was three and always hit with him.”
In high school, Rob made it to the quarterfinals at States. Flash forward 14 years or so. Rob Ferrante, now 27, is a tennis teaching pro at the Saw Mill Club where his sister practices. Little sister Caitlyn, now a high school junior, won the state championship as a sophomore — the first Yorktown girl to do so — and is undefeated this season.
“She’s incredibly good and she keeps getting better,” says Dayer, “already the best player we’ve ever had.” Dayer, it might be noted, is in his 28th year of coaching tennis.
“Her serve used to be below the rest of her game,” the coach said, “but she’s picked it up.” “That’s so,” agreed the light-haired 5-foot, 7-inch Ferrante. “And I’m fitter; I work out a lot. So I’m quicker.” And smarter. “She’s got mental toughness and she believes in herself,” the coach said. “She studies her opponent’s game and analyzes how to beat it. Plus she’s got no ego — a tremendous teammate who’s always willing to help the other girls.”
Last year, the sophomore Ferrante did go through the regular season unbeaten but lost in the sectionals to Briarcliff’s unseeded Rachel Lim. But she got to state competition where she avenged the loss to Lim and in the finals defeated Our Lady of Mercy’s Julia Andreach despite losing the first set by 6-1. It was on Halloween, no less.
“She did something at States I doubt has ever been done or ever will be done again,” Dayer said. “She defeated the Number 1, Number 2 and Number 4 seeds in order to win.” Caitlyn Ferrante couldn’t do that this October since she will certainly be a top seed. But she certainly could win again though still only a junior.
So what does she think about a repeat? “That would be awesome!”
October 4, 2017 | admin
By Chuck Slater
Ryan Elliott hopes to continue football in college. (PHOTO COURTESY OF RYAN ELLIOTT)
Early in the pre-season, Jack Gilroy, the senior defensive end on the Somers football team, said it best. “We have a state championship in mind again,” he said. Indeed, the Tuskers won the state in an extended 13-game season, stunning the Yorktown team that beat it early in the season by 42-6 in the sectional title game; then winning three more playoffs. This season, with the bulk of their offense having graduated, they are 3-0 but beat a tough Rye squad 21-14 on six forced turnovers despite being out-gained by over 100 yards. The two upcoming tests against Lourdes and John Jay-Cross River should tell veteran coach Tony DeMatteo more about his team.
“Are we as good as last year? At this point—no,” DeMatteo said. “If you consider how we may improve like last year—yes. But we lost two star running backs (Messiah Horne and Matt Pires).” “Our defense is capable of anything it did last year,” said senior cornerback Ryan Elliott. “The offense will find its way.”
Perhaps more than any other Tusker, the 5-foot, 10-inch, 165-pound Elliott was responsible for the defeat of Rye. He had three interceptions to go with the three in the opening week 48-1 rout of Poughkeepsie, when two of them went for touchdowns, allowing Somers to go with second stringers for most of the game.
“We proved that we are back again,” Elliott said after the opener. After Game 2, he said, “If they keep throwing my way, I’ll keep making plays on them. My goal was five picks for the entire season. Now? I’m going to keep going.”
Elliott, whose father, Rick, concentrated on baseball in high school, has been playing football for 10 years, starting with flag football. He has been a varsity starter for three years. He also figures to start at defensive midfield for the lacrosse varsity this spring. But football is his first love. “I love it because it’s a team game,” he said. “You can’t rely on just one player.” And college? “I haven’t picked a school yet,” the senior said. “But I would like to play football in college.”
Against Rye, DeMatteo felt last year’s marathon season has benefited this year’s squad. “A lot of our kids played 13 games (last season),” the coach said. “That’s a lot of games, and I think it has helped us.”
DeMatteo owns a record 336 victories in his 49th head-coaching season. Did someone say retire? Not the coach. “When I get a good night’s sleep before practice or a game, then I know I have to walk away,” Tony DeMatteo said. “I’m still getting up three or four times a night.”
September 27, 2017 | admin
By Chuck Slater
To say the Somers girls soccer team and Coach Paul Saia have outstanding records every year is an understatement. Saia, in his 16th season with the perennially successful Somers program, has just started his fourth year as head coach. In his first season, the team was a 22-0 state champion. In his second, it was a 20-1 section champion. Last season, his 15-3 squad lost the section final to Pearl River, 2-1.
This year? Well, let’s just say that being so good could be a challenge. Four key players have gone the graduation route and are currently on D-1 teams. Superstar forward Ciara Ostrander is at Yale. Superstar midfielder-forward Melina Couzis has her stick in UConn’s starting lineup. Defensive standout Mary Murphy and superb forward Jenna Menta are also cap-and-gown losses.
But that isn’t all. The recent rule disqualifying girls who played academy soccer means Somers is without junior forward Katrina Curtz and midfielder Ali Kalayjian. So you can count on one hand the returning starters.
Did anyone suggest a rebuilding season? Not Saia. “I feel very good about my team,” the coach said. “We’re going to have a lot of depth. We always field a successful squad. Maybe not so many superstars, but we are very well balanced. Right up to the opener (September 6 in a 16-game regular-season schedule), I wasn’t sure who would be starting at some positions.”
Claire Mensi is looking forward to multiple positions. (PHOTO COURTESY OF CLAIRE MENSI)
And then there is senior Claire Mensi, arguably his best player. Saia isn’t sure where the versatile 6-footer who was an all-section defenseman last season may be on the field at any time. “Anywhere and everywhere,” he says simply. Except of course as goalie. That job belongs to senior Lauren Jockimo, who shared the role last year with a graduation loss. “She did very well,” Saia said of Jockimo. “She didn’t allow many goals.”
Senior returning defender Amanda Brugger should be a big help to the goalie and the coach is high on sophomore defender Alexis Atkinson. Another sophomore, Jessica Rodriguez, should have a big role up front.
A healthy Mensi is crucial. Last year the tall defender, who relinquished varsity basketball to concentrate on soccer and has a scholarship to Bucknell, played seven games despite a foot fracture. But she then missed the rest of the season for an operation. Who knows if her presence might have affected that section final loss. “I think I would have helped,” says Mensi cautiously. The girl who started soccer at age three “and has loved it and its speed ever since” welcomes the any-position-at-any-time coach’s plan.
“I love it,” she says enthusiastically. “I love being able to play different positions. I look forward to leading the girls.”
September 20, 2017 | admin
By Chuck Slater
Success and failure are still major parts of the career of Jamie Loeb, the young tennis professional from Ossining. Now 22, the 5-foot, 6-inch athlete with the big forehand and two-handed backhand dropped out of Ossining High for home schooling after a sophomore season in which she won the state scholastic singles title. She wanted to devote full time to a tennis future.
After winning the NCAA individual championship at North Carolina University in 2015, she received a wild-card invitation to the U.S. Open but her own debilitating back injury and a fourth-seeded opponent in the first round added up to a quick exit.
She hasn’t made it back since to the American grand-slam championship which is currently ongoing. But she came close this year — boy, did she ever come close.
Jamie Loeb doesn’t regret her tennis-first decision. (PHOTO COURTESY OF JAMIE LOEB)
To qualify for the main draw, a hopeful for the big event must win three qualifying matches. Loeb won two in late August, routing NaLae Han of Korea, 6-4, 6-2, then outlasting the tough Russian Vera Zvonareva, 7-6, 5-7, 6-4. But, needing just one further win, the day after beating Zvonareva she fell to the talented Floridian, Sachia Vickery, 6-3, 6-4, in a match as tight as the score would indicate. And adding a touch of irony, Vickery had been Loeb’s practice partner for the matches ahead during the week.
“To come so close and not make it, it definitely hurts,” said a downcast Loeb shortly after the match. Counting her loss to Vickery, Loeb’s match record this year is 17-12 despite her hard work, dedication and talent. It is slightly better in doubles, where she has always excelled. She usually comes out first in one pro event a year — not one of the majors, of course.
Loeb’s next play-for-pay effort will start September 11 in Canada. And she now has an additional challenge: Her long-time, New York-based coach Felix Alverado, who has often accompanied her to tournaments, is moving to Florida. He has, however promised to be there for Loeb and she has decided to retain him. Alverado believes in his young athlete more than anyone except perhaps Loeb herself and her devoted family. “She needs to get in the top 100, the top 50,” he has said. “Jamie Loeb hits the ball as well as the girls in the top 20. And she works very hard. She wants it.”
You have to want it a lot. If you are not one of the girls in the top 50, the life of a traveling competitive tennis pro is not an easy one. You must handle your own travel arrangements and meals and do it as economically as possible while being alone in many strange places. In Loeb’s lone tournament victory this year, a $60,000 event back in February in Tasmania, the winner’s share was just $9,000.
But the girl who was introduced to racket sports by brother Jason before she could walk still has that overwhelming love of her sport despite hardships. Does she regret, she was asked, that decision to put tennis first after her sophomore year of high school? “Oh no, definitely not,” she said with the same firmness she hits a forehand.
September 13, 2017 | admin
By Chuck Slater
Has Caroline Cahill, Lakeland’s senior all-state midfielder, ever played in a losing game for her high school? “Not for Lakeland,” she says. “But I have played in losing games on club teams.”
Caroline Cahill has never lost a varsity game. (PHOTO COURTESY OF CAROLINE CAHILL)
Lakeland has won eight straight state field hockey championships, and Cahill has been on the last three, starting with her freshman year. But there has been the occasional tie along the way, and overconfidence is not part of her game. “Nothing is a given,” she says. “We have to put in our all — all the time.”
Perhaps even more so this year for nonpareil coach Sharon Sarson, — “She’s a legend,” praises Cahill as Sarson heads into her 36th year coaching field hockey with 17 Section 1 crowns in her belt. Three starting forwards and two starting defenders have gone the graduation route, certainly a challenge for any coach. If it fazes Sarson, she hides it well. “You lose key players every year,” she says. “Regenerating is common. Are we as strong as the last few years? I don’t even know. We’re looking to improve at practice every day and then in games.” Games started at the end of August. And this season the Hornets’ up-tempo game has an added challenge. Their field has new turf, safer but softer.
The eight consecutive state titles are an accomplishment so mind-boggling that it more than doubles what has ever been accomplished in the history of New York State high school team sports. The most any other team in any sport at any class has done is three straight.
Replacing the firepower lost up front will go partly to junior Julianna Capello, a super-sub last year who has been frustrating goalies in practice, and to Cahill, who is expected to produce increased offense from midfield. Cahill, who will be playing for James Madison next year, has a fellow senior all-starter returning at midfield in high-scoring Kelsey McCrudden. And Sarson’s always vaunted defense will again be led by standout senior goalie Cassie Halpin, headed for North Carolina-Chapel Hill. Last year’s state title was won on 1-0 semifinal and final games.
“We’ll be a different team but intense,” said McCrudden, who will play for SUNY Albany next year. “Will we be as good? I hope so,” Cahill said. “But right now our only goal is the Section 1 title.”
And of course there is Sarson, affectionately called “Sars” by her players. The R word – retirement – is starting to be brought up to her. “Yes, I’ve thought about it,” she admits, “but I still enjoy what I am doing.”
September 6, 2017 | admin